Cultural Appropriation: Not Just an Anomaly

3223223918_8c26b9105d_o

Cultural appropriation is something we do almost everyday of our lives as the world around us become more global and different cultures interact with each other. As stated in The Open Letter to Non-Native Wearing Headdress, by âpihtawikosisân, admiration for other cultures isn’t the true issue at hand, but rather the taking, copying, and appropriation of sacred cultural symbols from another culture for personal use and it can be very harmful especially when that culture has been oppressed. For someone to take a sacred symbol from another culture and using it outside of it’s cultural context and ascribe new meanings to the sacred object and perpetuate harmful stereotypes that not all people within that culture do not subscribe to. Cultural appropriation although having been used almost everyday, the mis-use of sacred cultural materials and symbols are detrimental to the oppressed culture, that the appropriator so wishes to emulate and it happens more often that one would believe.
A common example of cultural appropriation happens around Halloween when those who choose to dress up, decide to dress up and represent an entire culture. There are even many costumes available for sale such as, the Terrorist, a Geisha, Native American, Mexican and the list goes on, but all of these costumes have something in common. The take an aspect or a stereotypical fact about a culture and when that costume is worn the mis-representation, and lack of cultural context begins to take it’s toll, and this is especially true for Native American peoples. Their culture and it’s symbols are constantly being appropriated from insensitive Coachella goers, to halloween costumes, and even Caribanna costumes the miss use of the headdress is a symbol that is typically earned, and only for men. Yet, that symbol has been taken and mis-used constantly, and from the mis-use of this headdress, the feathers, the Native traditional dress in general we then generate stereotypes and generalized beliefs about that culture. Once again those symbols are part of traditional dress and especially today those pieces of clothing aren’t worn all the time, and it would be very easy for anyone to assume that those traditional pieces and those traditional pieces alone create the “Imaginary Indian” who is never truly authentic or indian enough, because the indigenous peoples today are in reality not any of these stereotypes.
These outdated views of indigenous peoples seem to lie within Canada’s roots in colonialism. As much of Europe sought to conquer the Americas for their own personal gain it is quite obvious that these views have carried over and aspects of colonialism still exist today. Even today Canada doesn’t treat their indigenous peoples with the respect that they deserve, as Canada and all it’s immigrants are the biggest squatters in history. Canada has taken away the control of their land, natural resources and even dictate the way in which indigenous communities live. Many Indigenous peoples do live in very poor conditions and often still feel a disconnect between themselves and their indigenous culture as the residential schools have taken so much away. Indigenous populations are dwindling and many are ending up in jail especially females and because of this they are being treated as a dying culture. Canada often denies the fact that we’ve had any racist or colonialist history by painting ourselves as a multicultural melting pot based in tolerance and less radical than our neighbours in the United States. Canada also paints itself as the saviours of a dying culture. When in fact Canada should be looking to not suppress and oppress our indigenous people but help them grow and give them the respect for their land upon which we’ve been using.
Through cultural appropriation reenforcing these stereotypes and micro/ macro aggressions against that culture/race one cannot deny the presence of systemic racism. It’s these harmful stereotypes that have put down the cultures outside of the white dominant group for many many years. An example of racism for the indigenous people of Canada are residential schools which sought eradicate indigenous cultures and languages until the last one closed in 1996. Much of the indigenous peoples who’ve attended these schools lost everything from their connection to their people and their culture to their own language. A census of the aboriginal population in 2006, found that only 22% percent of the Aboriginal populations have knowledge about their native language (Stats Canada) and knowledge according to stats Canada refers to, “ the ability to conduct a conversation in an Aboriginal language. The ‘on reserve’ population includes all people living in any of eight census subdivision (CSD) types legally affiliated with First Nations or Indian bands, as well as selected CSDs of various other types which have large concentrations of registered Indians. The ‘on reserve’ population is defined according to criteria established by Indian and Northern Affairs Canada.” (Stats Canada, 2006) This is a painful reminder of the detriment that residential schools have put on the generations of indigenous peoples and whilst there has been much focus on reviving the languages of the first nations, there is still much to recover.
By culturally appropriating you are reenforcing the stereotypes that are harmful to a culture and it’s people, if ever there was an opportunity in which you are afraid your culturally appropriating in a harmful way ask yourself: Are the symbols/ object you are using sacred items? Are those sacred items being used for their cultural/ original purpose? Are you using those symbols to represent an entire culture? Were you invited to participate in the culture by member of that culture? If the answer to these questions were No or Maybe perhaps you should re-think your costume/ the use of the cultural symbol. Or You can use the bingo chart above that is also linked int he open letter.

Source: http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/89-645-x/2010001/c-g/c-g008-eng.htm

http://apihtawikosisan.com/hall-of-shame/an-open-letter-to-non-natives-in-headdresses/

955 words

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Cultural Appropriation: Not Just an Anomaly

  1. Great job! This really helped me because I’m always trying to define what exactly cultural appropriation is and how to decide what is and is not cultural appropriation and your paper definitely helped me better understand that. Every time I see when the last residential school was closed it always surprises and upsets me. I was born in 96′ so they really haven’t been closed for that long and to think about how long they Canadian government let this go on just sickens me. I really liked your point about how cultural appropriation creates a falseness about that culture and kind of creates a standard or stereotype that people within that cultural have to live up to and if they don’t they are never seen as “truly authentic” by society. You just had a few grammatical errors throughout but beside that really great paper and analysis of this topic! 🙂

    Like

  2. Great thought provoking paper! I definitely see a lot of cultural appropriation in Canada, even though we are known for multiculturalism. It is especially frustrating when people use cultural appropriation to “appreciate” that culture without knowing the meaning of the symbols or the historical context behind them. As a Korean, I see many cultural appropriation in media, as well as everyday life, that often uses things from China and Japan to “represent” Korea. I would also like to address the use of a particular version of the Japanese flag, which consists of a red circle in the middle with 16 red lines stretching out from the circle. This flag was used during WWII when Japan invaded Korea, and it was used to represent the “superiority” of Japan. It embodies the countless massacres and gruesome violence against Koreans and the Korean culture, thus , I, personally, would equate the flag to the Nazi symbol. However, most people, including some Japanese these days, are not aware of the historical context and still use the symbol because it looks “cool” and “exotic”. Because I’ve experienced cultural appropriation used against my culture, your post and the article reminded me to be cautious and do some research before borrowing symbols from other cultures, even if I have good intention and want to appreciate that certain culture.

    Like

  3. Great analysis on cultural appropriation! It’s sad how much cultural appropriation is in our culture, and in our media. Its so easy to be spotted in our society such as music videos, halloween costumes, and even in television in movies. I think we take it for granted that we are considered a multicultural country and do not actually take the time to think about what these symbols mean to other cultures, and the origin and history behind them. As having a few really close friends who are part of the Aboriginal community, they have made me more aware of the cultural appropriation that happens with native symbols such as the dream catcher and how our society can be seen as making a mockery of them. I really liked the point you made talking about how stereotypes come from these cultural appropriation and teach people a false sense of culture. Great analysis on the topic!

    Like

  4. I enjoyed reading your blog post on the open letter. I always think it’s interesting that it is the same people who attempt to eradicate a culture that will then turn around and appropriate it. Do you think that appropriation is used as a way to terminate a culture, by underrating what a culture chooses to celebrate? After reading the open letter and relating our professor’s statement about orientalism to the cultural appropriation of the indigenous community by Canadians; I really believe how Canada portrays indigenous people says more about Canadians than it does the indigenous.
    -srhs

    Like

  5. Thanks for letting me know about the grammatical errors! To be honest I was in a bit of a rush during the creation of this blog. It’s interesting to learn about the misrepresentation of Korean/ Chinese/ Japanese predicaments, I’m sure it happens a lot! To be honest I wasn’t a good person in first year i had appropriated Native American culture and I was greeted with so much support in fact only one person called me out and I’m glad they did, because it led to my education about the topic and now it’s something I’m very passionate about stopping! I realize now it hurts people and if anyone ever finds that picture i will hold my head high apologize and say that I genuinely know better know and I’m doing my damned to stop this shit, because it hurts people. I don’t personally feel appropriation is meant to terminate a culture… more like make it into their own. You know what I mean? Like to some how absorb this culture into another which can be problematic in terms of identity. Kinda like Aztec culture they were literally wiped out and killed by columbus but aspects of their culture resonate within the Mexican communities. Yeah, I just wish I could show how damn sorry I am to the Native peoples and so I guess this is the way to do it. In general I wasn’t a nice person in high school and I basically consider first year an extension of that. I come from a rich Jamaican background and I dunno why I wanted to be anything else but that.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s